• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Employee Benefits Law Group

Employee Benefits Law Group

Guidance. More than just Legal Advice.

  • What We Do
    • ESOPs
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Governmental Employee Benefits
    • Retirement Plans
    • Equity & Executive Compensation
    • Health & Welfare Plans
  • Our Team
  • Resources
  • Contact
Employee Benefits Law Group
Home > Resources > Government > Public Employer Plans: Giving Employees Benefit Choices Can Lead To Problems

Public Employer Plans: Giving Employees Benefit Choices Can Lead To Problems

April 23, 2019 by Employee Benefits Law Group

When our public agency clients negotiate with their collectively bargained employees, both sides strive to make the most of limited compensation and benefits dollars. Sometimes the parties believe they can create greater value by letting the employees choose between two employer-provided benefits. In many cases, the choice between two employer-provided benefits does not include the ability for the employees to receive cash instead of employer-provided benefits.

Such a situation avoids a constructive receipt problem. There are many perils of letting employees choose between cash and nontaxable benefits. However, a lesser known tax problem can arise when a choice is given to employees between additional deferred compensation (an employer contribution to a 457(b) plan or a 401(a) plan) and an additional health insurance subsidy (an employer contribution for health insurance). This lesser-known problem stems from the “assignment of income” doctrine.

Choices May Mean Taxes

A number of U.S. Supreme Court cases uphold the proposition that if a taxpayer who is entitled to receive income in the future gives up that right (generally by surrendering it to another taxpayer), the taxpayer will be treated for tax purposes as having first received the “future income” and then disposing of it. How does the assignment of income doctrine cause a choice between an employer-made 457(b) plan contribution and an employer-made health premium subsidy? It’s because the employee’s choice is between the receipt of future income (amounts that will be taxed when distributed from the 457(b) plan) and a nontaxable current benefit (tax-free employer subsidy of health coverage).

If the employee gives up the right to receive additional 457(b) distributions in the future in exchange for an additional current health insurance subsidy, the IRS views this as an assignment of income and treats it as current taxable income to the employees who elect the additional health insurance subsidy – even though they are not receiving any cash and have elected to receive what appears to be a nontaxable benefit.

A cafeteria plan does not avoid the additional taxable income. Even if the employee could otherwise reduce taxable compensation on a pre-tax basis for health insurance premiums under the cafeteria plan, a cafeteria plan cannot allow a choice between nontaxable health benefits and deferred compensation. Therefore, the employee’s choice is not being made under the cafeteria plan so the choice does not result in a pre-tax health insurance premium deduction.

We have advised several cities about changes they wanted to make to their benefit plans. Fortunately, our clients had city attorneys who were sophisticated (and current) enough to recognize the potential tax issue and worked with us to resolve it. As we all know, novel employee benefit ideas such as the one mentioned above tend to make the “rounds” as cities and districts renegotiate their memorandums of understanding (MOUs). For every public agency that addresses this issue, there probably are dozens more that are unaware of the problem.

Playing It Safe

Employers and their collective bargaining partners should be particularly careful when negotiating and designing benefit changes that involve employee choice. To ensure optimal results with no surprises for employers, collective-bargaining partners and employees, work with benefits law experts at Employee Benefits Law Group.

Filed Under: Government Tagged With: Blog

About Employee Benefits Law Group

Employee Benefits Law Group is a deep and diverse team of experts working to make your life easier and improve your outcomes in every aspect of employee benefits. Our clients know we listen, probe and understand their challenges and objectives. We ask the questions they didn't know needed to be asked. They count on us to deliver solutions that become part of their company's overall success.

Meet the Team

EDITOR’S NOTE: We did the best we could to make sure the information and advice in this article were current as of the date of posting to the web site. Because the laws and the government’s rules are changing all the time, you should check with us if you are unsure whether this material is still current. Of course, none of our articles are meant to serve as specific legal advice to you. If you would like that, please call us at (916) 357-5660.

Recent Government Employee Benefits Posts

It Pays to Give Your Retirement Plan A Comprehensive Review

Participant-Directed Retirement Plans: How California Public Employers Sponsoring Them Can Reduce Their Fiduciary Risk

GASB Statements 43 And 45 – The Financial Disclosure Rules

Don’t Miss Out! Subscribe

We cover all things employee benefits law.

Privacy Policy

We never share your info.

Let’s Start a Conversation

Have questions about your current benefit plan? Want to know what your benefit plan options are? Whatever your need, we’re here to help. Fill out a hassle-free request form, and one of our team members will follow up to get you on the path to success.

Get In Touch

Footer

Our experienced team guides you in all aspects of ESOPs, M&A due diligence, retirement plans, equity / compensation, and health and welfare benefits.
Sacramento Office
916-357-5660
11231 Gold Express Dr.
Suite 108
Gold River, CA 95670
San Jose Office
408-467-3860
2033 Gateway Place
Suite 500
San Jose, CA 95110
Phoenix Office
2550 W. Union Hills Dr.
Phoenix, AZ 85027
Los Angeles Office
310-571-8896
10880 Wilshire Blvd
Suite 1101
Los Angeles, CA
90024
San Diego Office
916-357-5660
550 West B Street
San Diego, CA 92101
  • LinkedIn
  • Email

Copyright © 2023 Employee Benefits Law Group · Privacy Policy · Site Design by Delos Incorporated