• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Employee Benefits Law Group

Employee Benefits Law Group

Guidance. More than just Legal Advice.

  • What We Do
    • ESOPs
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Retirement Plans
    • Equity & Executive Compensation
    • Health & Welfare Plans
  • Our Team
  • Resources
  • Contact
Employee Benefits Law Group
Home > Resources > Retirement Plans > Switching Record-Keepers? Avoid Common Pitfalls

Switching Record-Keepers? Avoid Common Pitfalls

April 23, 2019 by Employee Benefits Law Group

Plan sponsors seriously disadvantage themselves and their plan participants by announcing the migration of their plan from one record-keeper to a new record-keeper before all the conditions for a smooth transition have been fulfilled.

There are record-keepers that know this and take full advantage of it. Usually, the plan sponsor is so happy to have “completed” its RFP process that it treats the selection of a record-keeper as the end of the migration process – rather than its beginning. Unfortunately, once the identity of the new record-keeper has been announced to the employees and participants, the employer (plan sponsor) is committed and has begun to box itself in from a contract negotiating standpoint.

We recently helped a client that took an all-too-common “shoot then aim” approach to choosing a new record-keeper. A sophisticated municipal 457(b) plan with thousands of participants and hundreds of millions of dollars in plan assets, they had chosen and announced a new record-keeper before fully negotiating and understanding the new deal.

Under the circumstances, we did the best we could to negotiate the best arrangement, but the new record-keeper was keenly aware of the situation, so it was very hard to obtain the contractual and fee concessions that one might obtain before a deal is signed. In another record-keeper conversion for a large special district, the change and anticipated conversion date were announced to participants prior to the resolution of all conversion issues. Due to the lack of planning, the actual conversion date had to be postponed and negotiations with both the old and the new record-keepers continued up to the last minute.

Careful Planning Provides Protection

Both of these cases – and dozens like them – are easily avoided.

Choosing to change your plan record-keeper requires careful deliberation and planning to protect both plan sponsor and participants. Before announcing the migration of the plan to a new record-keeper, be sure all the conditions for a smooth transition have been fulfilled. We’ll show you how. 

Don’t rely on the new record-keeper to protect the plan. As a plan sponsor it is tempting to relax after a tough RFP process, but the selection of a record-keeper is really the beginning of the plan migration process. Once the identity of the new record-keeper has been announced to the employees and participants, the sponsor is committed and has much less negotiating power. As the transition date approaches, the plan sponsor and retirement committee or fiduciaries are forced to either concede or compromise.

Here are some common issues that are often not nailed down as part of the selection process:

  • Compensation. What is the exact amount the record-keeper is being paid and on what basis? Some record-keepers win business with an apparently low fee (in terms of basis points). These low fees often come with an “understanding” that the record-keeper’s stable value fund (and/or other of the record-keeper’s proprietary funds) will be offered as part of the new investment lineup. If a stable value fund will be part of the mix, the provider’s related annuity contract must be reviewed and accepted. Unless you can identify all of the types of revenue that the new record-keeper will receive in connection with your plan, you won’t know if it’s fair and proper for all of your participants. Fully analyzing, negotiating and documenting all fees and revenues is an essential pre-condition to announcing a new provider.
  • The Administrative Services Agreement (ASA). The terms and conditions of the ASA are critical. Most ASAs are prepared by the record-keeper’s attorneys and designed to protect the record-keeper and its affiliates. Carefully examine, negotiate and document these “hot spots” in most ASAs:
    • Choice of law
    • Venue for resolving disputes
    • Whether there will be mandatory arbitration/mediation
    • Limitations of the provider’s liability
    • Indemnification
    • Non-solicitation of participants

The overall scope of contracted services needs to be carefully analyzed and understood by the parties. Oftentimes, providers will refer to an “administration manual,” which they will use to record-keep the plan. Because this document will become the go-to reference for the record-keeper’s staff (not the actual plan documents), it is critical for the plan sponsor to carefully review and edit this document.

Filed Under: Retirement Plans Tagged With: Blog

About Employee Benefits Law Group

Employee Benefits Law Group is a deep and diverse team of experts working to make your life easier and improve your outcomes in every aspect of employee benefits. Our clients know we listen, probe and understand their challenges and objectives. We ask the questions they didn't know needed to be asked. They count on us to deliver solutions that become part of their company's overall success.

Meet the Team

EDITOR’S NOTE: We did the best we could to make sure the information and advice in this article were current as of the date of posting to the web site. Because the laws and the government’s rules are changing all the time, you should check with us if you are unsure whether this material is still current. Of course, none of our articles are meant to serve as specific legal advice to you. If you would like that, please call us at (916) 357-5660.

Recent Retirement Plans Posts

Controlled Group or Affiliated Service Group? What That Means for Your 401(k) Plan Compliance

Form 5500: The Role of the Accountant and the Audit Report

Coverage Rules For 401(k)’s and Other Qualified Plans – Part 3. Average Benefit Test and the Minimum Participation Rule

Don’t Miss Out! Subscribe

We cover all things employee benefits law.

Privacy Policy

We never share your info.

Let’s Start a Conversation

Have questions about your current benefit plan? Want to know what your benefit plan options are? Whatever your need, we’re here to help. Fill out a hassle-free request form, and one of our team members will follow up to get you on the path to success.

Get In Touch

Footer

Our experienced team guides you in all aspects of ESOPs, M&A due diligence, retirement plans, equity / compensation, and health and welfare benefits.
Sacramento Office
916-357-5660
11231 Gold Express Dr.
Suite 108
Gold River, CA 95670
San Jose Office
408-467-3860
2033 Gateway Place
Suite 500
San Jose, CA 95110
Phoenix Office
2550 W. Union Hills Dr.
Phoenix, AZ 85027
Los Angeles Office
310-571-8896
10880 Wilshire Blvd
Suite 1101
Los Angeles, CA
90024
San Diego Office
916-357-5660
550 West B Street
San Diego, CA 92101
  • LinkedIn
  • Email

Copyright © 2025 Employee Benefits Law Group · Privacy Policy · Site Design by Delos Incorporated