• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Employee Benefits Law Group

Employee Benefits Law Group

Guidance. More than just Legal Advice.

  • What We Do
    • ESOPs
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Retirement Plans
    • Equity & Executive Compensation
    • Health & Welfare Plans
  • Our Team
  • Resources
  • Contact
Employee Benefits Law Group
Home > Resources > ESOP > ESOP Reverse Allocations

ESOP Reverse Allocations

September 9, 2019 by Employee Benefits Law Group

This article describes the use of reverse allocations in Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) companies to provide a meaningful number of shares for newer and younger employees and to help ensure the ESOP’s sustainability.

ESOPs reward longevity and provide a meaningful stake in a company’s success. For ESOP companies that started with large initial sales of shares to the plan, shares can over-accumulate to those with tenure. This could happen to the dismay of newer employees who may not have the opportunity to accumulate a meaningful number of shares in their ESOP accounts.

Companies that face the challenge of making equity sharing and participation in their ESOP plan more meaningful to newer and younger employees may consider the option of a reverse allocation. This approach alters the ESOP ownership structure to provide a greater opportunity to newer employees.

Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) reward longevity and provide a meaningful stake in a company’s success. For ESOP companies that started with large initial sales of shares to the plan, shares can over-accumulate to those with tenure to the dismay of newer employees who may not have the opportunity to accumulate a meaningful number of shares in their ESOP accounts.

These ESOP companies face the challenge of how to make equity sharing and participation in the plan more meaningful to newer and younger employees. Companies may consider using “reverse allocations” in their ESOPs to alter the ESOP ownership structure and to provide a greater ESOP opportunity to newer employees.

The Challenges of Success

In one case, a client underwent a leveraged ESOP transaction to purchase 51% of a company from its owner. Due to rapid growth, the company paid off the deal much faster than planned. Suddenly, 51% of ownership was in employee accounts. Although the company knew it needed to provide retirement benefits to new employees, they appeared to be unable to participate in the already allocated 51% of ownership. That fact particularly mattered at a point when the company was expanding and needed to hire new employees.

Reverse allocations require a broader view of the ESOP’s objectives – shared ownership, but with an understanding of the “total benefit experience” the plan offers every employee. A reverse allocation permits the ESOP to allocate shares to allow more stock participation for newer employees than tenured employees – either with shares that are purchased or distributed from over-accumulated accounts, or with new cash or stock contributions.

These creative ESOP plan designs evaluate the total workforce benefit levels and target share allocations within the IRS rules that require nondiscrimination in benefits.

ESOP reverse allocations present many design challenges. Guidance from an experienced ESOP team providing both the legal advice and consulting experience is key.

Creative Solutions

To solve the issue, an experienced employee benefits law firm that’s highly proficient in ESOPs brought a fresh perspective. They rethought the presumption that the ESOP had to function the same way the second time around.

Starting with a blank slate, the firm began by asking questions and questioning assumptions. The client wanted to offer all employees a meaningful share in the ESOP’s ownership of the company.

The original plan had started in 2006 and was designed to allocate a lot of stock – using standard allocation methods – driven by the size of the transaction. The chips fell where they landed. Under the new 2015 plan design, the firm focused on whom they needed to benefit and worked backward from there to design the formulas to allocate shares and define funding levels and sources.

Newer employees were grouped by their own tenure and compensation levels, and then targeted stock and nonstock benefit levels. Each of the relevant design criteria was tested to ensure the design met IRS nondiscrimination requirements. The design was customized to meet the objective.

As a result, the plan welcomed the newest employees who had the least shares, effectively creating a new ESOP going forward. The firm accomplished this fairly by analyzing the overall benefit levels within the plan, determining meaning within it and applying the tests required to ensure it was compliant and effective.

Finding Fairness

Attracting and retaining new employees will support ESOP sustainability, which is where an ESOP reverse allocation comes in. Ideally, reverse allocations provide shares favoring newer employees to help them “catch up” to longer-tenured employees. However, the design must also provide and maintain benefit levels for all employees when measured, including stock, cash, dividend levels and other earnings in the plan. This expanded view of an ESOP addresses employee ownership and the true effectiveness of an ESOP as a retirement plan.

Other alternatives, of course, could be used to benefit new employees with stock-based incentives, such as restricted stock and stock appreciation rights, but these are not immediately tax-deductible by the company and don’t address divisions in the work force – they can worsen the problem.

ESOP Reverse Allocation: The Greater Benefit

The client was delighted with the solution, which met the corporation’s primary objective of avoiding over-concentration of stock accounts and sharing the 51% ownership of the company with all employees. Beyond that, it gave senior employee owners and managers a powerful tool for managing and incentivizing their workforce, no matter how fast it expanded.

Because of its essential fairness and transparency, the plan allowed middle management to promote cohesion and a positive workforce culture. Everyone had a chance to grab a brass ring, which helped greatly in hiring and retention. The senior managers were no longer the “haves” managing junior employees who were relegated to being “have-nots.”

Such plans could be applied during new acquisitions, expansions, mergers or in any number of other scenarios.

Count on Experts

ESOPs are created by lawyers and are layered in complexity. ESOP documents require expertise that even deeply experienced retirement plan administrators won’t have. An experienced employee benefits law firm with experienced embedded consulting talent knows the rules and regulations well enough to offer clever ways around roadblocks while staying fully compliant with rules in complex issues such as ESOP reverse allocations.

Finding the Right Partner

Find an ESOP attorney and an employee benefits law firm that listens to your objectives and has the talent and depth of experience to know how to guide you to them. Here are some questions to ask yourself prior to choosing an ESOP attorney and team:

  • Can they see the big picture? Do they view an ESOP as a single project, or holistically as a part of an entire benefits package?
  • Do they have both the legal and certified pension consulting resources in-house to evaluate issues and overcome any challenges you may face with an ESOP?
  • How much ESOP experience do they have and what is their track record?
  • Can they help communicate the plan to your workforce? A good firm will help your in-house people execute any ESOP and assist with every aspect of a benefits package.
  • Are they creative thinkers? Do they look for innovative options in plan design and consulting? Do they have the new ideas to help ensure key people and new employees get the benefits the company wants them to get – now and in the future?

Filed Under: ESOP Tagged With: ESOP, ESOP Attorney, ESOP Lawyer

About Employee Benefits Law Group

Employee Benefits Law Group is a deep and diverse team of experts working to make your life easier and improve your outcomes in every aspect of employee benefits. Our clients know we listen, probe and understand their challenges and objectives. We ask the questions they didn't know needed to be asked. They count on us to deliver solutions that become part of their company's overall success.

Meet the Team

EDITOR’S NOTE: We did the best we could to make sure the information and advice in this article were current as of the date of posting to the web site. Because the laws and the government’s rules are changing all the time, you should check with us if you are unsure whether this material is still current. Of course, none of our articles are meant to serve as specific legal advice to you. If you would like that, please call us at (916) 357-5660.

Recent ESOP Posts

Selling an ESOP Company

The Top 5 “Speed Bumps” When Terminating an ESOP

What Can an ESOP Invest in Other Than Company Stock?

Don’t Miss Out! Subscribe

We cover all things employee benefits law.

Privacy Policy

We never share your info.

Let’s Start a Conversation

Have questions about your current benefit plan? Want to know what your benefit plan options are? Whatever your need, we’re here to help. Fill out a hassle-free request form, and one of our team members will follow up to get you on the path to success.

Get In Touch

Footer

Our experienced team guides you in all aspects of ESOPs, M&A due diligence, retirement plans, equity / compensation, and health and welfare benefits.
Sacramento Office
916-357-5660
11231 Gold Express Dr.
Suite 108
Gold River, CA 95670
San Jose Office
408-467-3860
2033 Gateway Place
Suite 500
San Jose, CA 95110
Phoenix Office
2550 W. Union Hills Dr.
Phoenix, AZ 85027
Los Angeles Office
310-571-8896
10880 Wilshire Blvd
Suite 1101
Los Angeles, CA
90024
San Diego Office
916-357-5660
550 West B Street
San Diego, CA 92101
  • LinkedIn
  • Email

Copyright © 2025 Employee Benefits Law Group · Privacy Policy · Site Design by Delos Incorporated